Thursday, 5 May 2016

(Assignment 2) Comments on Assignment 1 - Arya Rani

Corruption in Nigeria- Nandini JB

The essay discusses corruption in Nigeria through the lens of social mechanisms that contribute to corruption. Although the author has described three different cases of financial corruptions and attributed the cause to neo-patrimonialism in Nigeria, the lack of in-depth analysis makes it problematic. A prominent question that arises in my mind is that can all the financial scandals (or at least the ones specified) be brought under the problem of neo-patrimonialism.

Spanish Salsa- Krupa

This essay also analyses corruption in Spain in the backdrop of the Spanish culture that seems to encourage abuse of public offices for private gains. The author discusses three cases that support this argument. The acknowledgement of citizens that corruption is a part of human nature or that corruption is part of Spanish culture somehow validates the acts of those in power. This complicates the understanding of corruption and mechanisms to curb it.

Piled Higher and Deeper: An Analysis of Denmark- Anand Sreekumar

The author’s selection of case study is very interesting. Denmark enjoys that status of least corrupt state in the world, hence unfolding of corruption in Denmark makes it intriguing. The essay points at two different points of corruption- weak transparency in political affairs of Denmark and foreign bribery. Keeping Aristotelian philosophy as the vantage point, Denmark’s case is analysed. But, perhaps because it is beyond the scope of this assignment, the analysis only mentions subjectivity and ceases to dig deeper.








No comments:

Post a Comment